Shooting a rutting buck is a bit different than a buck at other times of the season. Young bucks are more predictable than an older animal, and it's not uncommon for a young buck to stand motionless and get himself shot. Rutting bucks, even when still, always seem to be in motion. Their body is moving, the head is up and then down or sideways, and they often move when they first spot the doe. Tails flick, ears move, the head is up and down, and the animal is wound tighter than a cheap wind-up alarm clock. Hunters, especially when in a tree stand, may spot the doe before the buck and get ready for a shot.
This injured buck (see hump on shoulder) was always spooky.
Guessing a buck's actions opens a hunter up to making errors. I once watched a buck dogging a doe across a field to a hole in the fence. She jumped right through without stopping. I thought he'd do the same and made my release when his nose entered the hole.
The buck stopped instead of coming through and the arrow sliced harmlessly through the air and stuck in the ground. The buck then jumped through the hole, sniffed the arrow and took off after the doe. No big deal for him but a complete miss for me. So much for trying to second-guess a rutting buck. Some bucks act somewhat predictably and others do not. Study the buck, and it helps to be at full draw when the buck comes into sight. If the buck takes two or three steps and then stops, shoot the instant he stops if it offers a high percentage shot.Always expect the unexpected from rutting whitetails.
Sometimes a buck will head into the brush on a doe's trail, and stop before committing himself to the move. Be ready if he hesitates, but this isn't something a hunter can count on a buck doing. One thing that may be somewhat predictable is if you can find the does, the bucks won't be far away.
Snow during the rut makes makes bucks even more unprdictible.
One trick that works on occasion is to wait until the buck is in a perfect spot, and then grunt loud and guttural. A harsh grunt may stop a buck for an instant, but it fails as often as it works. Of course, the hunter can't grunt, raise the bow and shoot. He must be at full draw when he grunts to stop the animal.
The Boy Scouts of America has a motto: Be Prepared. It works for BSA members, and it certainly will pay off when bow hunting rutting bucks. Hunters who are not prepared, both mentally and physically, often miss their golden opportunity. The only thing deer hunters can count on is the unpredictability of whitetail bucks during the rut. Watch for it this fall, and see what I mean.
Jack O'Malley Interview w/ Dave Richey